• CSC20logograyorangenoyear
  • CSC 2022
      • About
        • About the Conference
        • Floor Plan / Sponsor List
        • Sponsors
        • FAQ
        • Contact Us
        • Health & Safety
      • Hotel & Travel
        • Hotel Accommodations
        • Travel Information
      • Attend
        • Why Attend?
        • Registration & Pricing
        • Conference Schedule
        • Speakers
        • Become a Speaker
        • MCLE Accreditation
      • Sponsor
        • Why Sponsor?
        • Sponsor / Inquire
        • Sponsor Resource Center
        • Sponsorship & Advertising
  • News
    • Latest News
  • Subscribe
    • Newsletter Signup
    • Show Updates
  • .
  • CSC 2022
    • About
      • About the Conference
      • Floor Plan / Sponsor List
      • Sponsors
      • FAQ
      • Contact Us
      • Health & Safety
    • Attend
      • Why Attend?
      • Registration & Pricing
      • Conference Schedule
      • Speakers
      • Become a Speaker
      • MCLE Accreditation
    • Sponsor
      • Why Sponsor?
      • Sponsor / Inquire
      • Sponsor Resource Center
      • Sponsorship & Advertising
    • Hotel & Travel
      • Hotel Accommodations
      • Travel Information
  • News
    • Latest News
  • Subscribe
    • Newsletter Signup
    • Show Updates

December 6 – 8, 2022 |
MGM Grand, Las Vegas

Sign Up Sponsor / Inquire
Q
POPULAR SEARCHES
News + Features
News + Features
News + Features
News + Features
News + Features
News + Features

Latest News

January 18, 2022

Perspective On Supreme Court Ruling

Latest News
January 18, 2022

Perspective On Supreme Court Ruling

by Frederick F. Butters

SOUTHFIELD, MI – I don’t believe the United States Supreme Court (USSC) ruling is as complex as it may seem. Individual states have historically issued vaccine mandates and they have been upheld. Likewise, while the precedent is scant, there appears to be no real question that Congress could enact such a mandate if it chose to do so.

There have been smallpox mandates historically that the USSC upheld, and every state has laws that require vaccination before one can attend school—although enforcement is spotty. Congress can also delegate certain authority to the Executive branch by virtue of statute, which of course would empower the Executive branch to make and enforce rules. That is really what was at issue.

The dispute arose when the Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) enacted the vaccine mandate rules for healthcare workers in medical facilities that receive federal money (virtually all of them). OSHA also enacted a parallel rule that applied to all employers with 100 or more employees. Several challenges were filed and the plaintiffs immediately sought orders barring implementation of the rules until the cases could be fully litigated. 

Frederick F. Butters

In an Ohio case challenging the OSHA rule, the District Court had refused to block it and the 6th Circuit court of Appeals concluded likewise. The specific challenge was based in statute and the specific argument was that while Congress had delegated to the Executive branch the authority to make and enforce rules that fostered workplace safety, it did not include in that grant of power the authority to regulate health related issues. Therefore, as Congress had not granted that authority (reserving it to itself) OSHA did not have the power to issue and enforce the rule. 

The USSC therefore reversed the 6th Circuit and entered an order blocking implementation. On the HHS rule the USSC reached the opposite conclusion. With respect to that rule, the USSC found that the applicable statutes granted the authority to formulate and implement a vaccine mandate to the Secretary of HHS. Therefore, when the HHS formulated and implemented that rule it was acting within the scope of authority Congress delegated to it – specifically to impose conditions on the grant and use of any government funds. 

As a consequence, the rule is valid and decisions by lower courts that had blocked implementation of the HHS rule were vacated (although there is a separate proceeding pending in Texas that has blocked it on the basis of different issues – that case was not part of what went before the USSC).

That isn’t the end; it was just the preliminary decision. The challenges will continue to be litigated in the lower courts and may eventually make their way back to the USSC. That said, the answer to the basic question of whether Congress has granted the requisite authority for these sorts of rules to the Executive branch won’t likely change. While Congress could take action, the divided nature of politics makes that extremely unlikely.

Frederick F. Butters, FAIA, Esq. is an attorney at law, Frederick F. Butters, PLLC, Southfield, Mich.

SHARE

Share on Email
Share on Linkedin
Share on Facebook
Share on Pinterest
Share on Twitter
← Previous Article Next Article →
Latest News Latest NewsNews

Biden Vows To Speed Environmental Reviews

WASHINGTON, D.C. – A new press release from the White House outlines a plan to release a new Permitting Action Plan to strengthen and accelerate Federal permitting and environmental reviews.

Latest News Latest NewsNews

AGC Urges End To Tariffs

ARLINGTON, VA - Prices of materials and services for nonresidential construction leaped nearly 21 percent from year-ago levels, according to an analysis by the Associated General Contractors of America of government data.

Latest News Latest NewsNews

Biden Vows To Speed Environmental Reviews

WASHINGTON, D.C. – A new press release from the White House outlines a plan to release a new Permitting Action Plan to strengthen and accelerate Federal permitting and environmental reviews.

Latest News Latest NewsNews

Pandemic Lessons Loom

LAS VEGAS – Everyone hopes the pandemic is a once-in-a-century event, but contract language never sleeps. Construction attorneys, contractors, and governments can learn from pandemic issues in a variety of ways.

Latest News Latest NewsNews

AGC Calls For Tariff Relief

AGC urged the Biden administration to relieve major cost pressures by removing remaining tariffs.

Latest News Latest NewsNews

Industry News: $125K Fine; White House Budget; Giordano Appointed

NEW YORK – New York Attorney General Letitia James announced via press release that her office secured $125,000 from a contractor who skirted diversity requirements.

Latest News Latest NewsNews

Pete Fowler Construction Services – A Problem Solver

SAN CLEMENTE, CA – After 25 years in the consulting business, the employees at Pete Fowler Construction Services (PFCS) have seen a lot. While much has changed since the San Clemente-based consulting firm opened its doors in 1997, some things r
Latest News Latest NewsNews

Supply Chain Delays: What Claim Issues Are You Seeing?

In many industries, the “supply chain” mantra is familiar and persistent. This month we continue the topic with a focus on claims specifically related to delays.

SHOW INFORMATION

SIGN UP

Register now for the opportunity to connect with thousands of atttendees and vendors

Sign Up
Sponsor / Inquire
FOLLOW US ON
  • Follow
  • Follow
  • Follow
© 2022 Emerald X, LLC. All Rights Reserved.

ABOUT    CAREERS    AUTHORIZED SERVICE PROVIDERS   TERMS OF USE   PRIVACY POLICY