• CSC20logograyorangenoyear
  • Conference
      • About
        • About the Conference
        • Floor Plan / Sponsor List
        • Sponsors
        • FAQ
        • Contact Us
        • Health & Safety
      • Hotel & Travel
        • Hotel Accommodations
        • Travel Information
      • Attend
        • Why Attend?
        • Registration & Pricing
        • Conference Schedule
        • MCLE Accreditation
        • Speakers
        • Speaker Resources
      • Sponsor
        • Why Sponsor?
        • Sponsor / Inquire
        • Sponsor Resource Center
        • Sponsorship & Advertising
  • News
    • Latest News
  • Subscribe
    • Newsletter Signup
    • Show Updates
  • .
  • Conference
    • About
      • About the Conference
      • Floor Plan / Sponsor List
      • Sponsors
      • FAQ
      • Contact Us
      • Health & Safety
    • Attend
      • Why Attend?
      • Registration & Pricing
      • Conference Schedule
      • MCLE Accreditation
      • Speakers
      • Speaker Resources
    • Sponsor
      • Why Sponsor?
      • Sponsor / Inquire
      • Sponsor Resource Center
      • Sponsorship & Advertising
    • Hotel & Travel
      • Hotel Accommodations
      • Travel Information
  • News
    • Latest News
  • Subscribe
    • Newsletter Signup
    • Show Updates

November 29—December 1, 2023
The Diplomat, Hollywood, FL

Register Sponsor / Inquire
Q
POPULAR SEARCHES
News + Features
News + Features
News + Features
News + Features
News + Features
News + Features

Latest News

June 27, 2018

California Supreme Court Clarifies the Use of Good Faith Withholdings in Payment Disputes

Latest News
Economic Forecasts | Ethics and Compliance | Infrastructure and Transportation | Insurance and Surety | Latest News | Litigation Strategies/Dispute Resolution | News | Risk & Contract Management | Workforce and Labor
June 27, 2018

California Supreme Court Clarifies the Use of Good Faith Withholdings in Payment Disputes

The Legislative intent of prompt payment statutes must be taken into account.

Both common law and statutory law prompt payment provisions allow a prime contractor to withhold payment to a subcontractor if there is a legitimate, good faith, issue concerning whether the subcontractor is owed the amount it claims.

The issue before the California Supreme Court in United Riggers & Erectors, Inc. v. Coast Iron and Steel Co., Case No. S231549 (May 14, 2018) was whether the prime contractor, Coastal, could withhold payments to its subcontractor, United, based upon disputes over other issues not directly related to the specific payments in dispute.

Decisions in lower California courts were split on this issue. Garret Murai’s article in the California Construction Law Blog, outlines the Supreme Court’s decision that provides a final ruling on this matter.

California has statutes that “provide a “’good faith” or ‘bona fide’ exception, in which a higher tiered party can withhold from a lower-tiered party up to 150% of any amount disputed in ‘good faith’ or in which there is a ‘bona fide’ dispute, without being subject to prompt payment statute’s credit card-like penalties for non-payment.”

In this case, in addition to a demand for unpaid retainage and related penalties for failure to promptly pay them, United demanded compensation for unpaid change orders and “‘damages attributed ‘to missing parts, lack of communication by Coast, fabrication errors, delays in installation of steel and lack of transportation access.’”

Coast claimed there was a “good faith” dispute over all the contested payments and therefore, relying upon California Civil Code section 8814, argued it could withhold 150% of all these items. This would have amounted to more than the unpaid retainage “that was never in dispute.”

The Supreme Court rejected Coast’s argument because it would have created a “windfall” for the defendant that was contrary to the intent of the relevant statutes.

Source—

California Supreme Court Addresses “Good Faith” construction Disputes Under Prompt Payment Laws, Garret Murai, California Construction Law Blog, May 29, 2018.

Economic Forecasts•Ethics and Compliance•Infrastructure and Transportation•Insurance and Surety•Latest News•Litigation Strategies/Dispute Resolution•News•Risk & Contract Management•Workforce and Labor

SHARE

Share on Email
Share on Linkedin
Share on Facebook
Share on Pinterest
Share on Twitter
← Previous Article Next Article →
Latest News Latest NewsNews

Construction Adds 15K Jobs

ARLINGTON, VA - The construction sector added 15,000 jobs in April while the sector’s unemployment rate fell to a record low for the month.

Latest News Latest NewsNews

Analysis: New NY Law To Ban Gas In New Buildings

Carol A. Sigmond, partner at Greenspoon Marder LLP, New York, N.Y. is sympathetic to the law’s intent, but has many concerns about the legislation.

Latest News Latest NewsNews

Construction Adds 15K Jobs

ARLINGTON, VA - The construction sector added 15,000 jobs in April while the sector’s unemployment rate fell to a record low for the month.

Latest News Latest NewsNews

Four Cozen O’Connor Attorneys Win Awards

PHILADELPHIA – Four attorneys from Cozen O'Connor have been recognized by The Legal Intelligencer with 2023 Professional Excellence Awards.

Latest News

Latest News Latest NewsNews

Termination Provisions: Avoiding Headaches

HOLLYWOOD, FL - With the topic still hot, Brent N. Mackay agreed to sit down with Third Thursday to offer his continuing thoughts on termination provisions.

Latest News Latest NewsNews

Construction Sheds Jobs

ARLINGTON, VA - The construction sector shed 9,000 jobs in March, the first decrease since January 2022.

Latest News Latest NewsNews

Spotlight – Workplace Safety

ALBANY, N.Y. – Last month, Third Thursday heard from Carol A. Sigmond, partner at New York-based Greenspoon Marder LLP. Sigmond analyzed the fallout from recent NY state legislation to increase penalties for criminal corporate liability.

SHOW INFORMATION

SIGN UP

Register now for the opportunity to connect with thousands of atttendees and vendors

Register
Sponsor / Inquire
FOLLOW US ON
  • Follow
  • Follow
  • Follow
© 2023 Emerald X, LLC. All Rights Reserved.

ABOUT    CAREERS    AUTHORIZED SERVICE PROVIDERS   TERMS OF USE   PRIVACY POLICY