• CSC tag_orngBlu
  • Conference
      • About
        • About the Conference
        • Floor Plan / Sponsor List
        • Sponsors
        • FAQ
        • Contact Us
        • Health & Safety
      • Hotel & Travel
        • Hotel Accomodations
        • Travel Information
      • Attend
        • Why Attend?
        • Registration & Pricing
        • Agenda At-A-Glance
        • Conference Schedule
        • MCLE Accreditation
        • Speakers
        • Speaker Resources
      • Sponsor
        • Why Sponsor?
        • Sponsor / Inquire
        • Sponsor Resource Center
        • Sponsorship & Advertising
  • News
    • Latest News
  • Subscribe
    • Newsletter Signup
  • .
  • Logo
  • Conference
    • [Column]
      • About
        • About the Conference
        • Floor Plan / Sponsor List
        • Sponsors
        • FAQ
        • Contact Us
        • Health & Safety
      • Hotel & Travel
        • Hotel Accomodations
        • Travel Information
    • [Column]
      • Attend
        • Why Attend?
        • Registration & Pricing
        • Agenda At-A-Glance
        • Conference Schedule
        • MCLE Accreditation
        • Speakers
        • Speaker Resources
    • [Column]
      • Sponsor
        • Why Sponsor?
        • Sponsor / Inquire
        • Sponsor Resource Center
        • Sponsorship & Advertising
    • [Column]
      • [Custom]
  • News
    • Latest News
  • Subscribe
    • Newsletter Signup
  • .

December 9-11, 2025
Hyatt Regency Coconut Point, Bonita Springs, FL

Register Sponsor
Q

Latest News

December 28, 2017

Terms of Subcontract Signed After a Project is Complete Can Be Applied Retroactively

Latest News
Economic Forecasts | Ethics and Compliance | Infrastructure and Transportation | Insurance and Surety | Latest News | Litigation Strategies/Dispute Resolution | News | Risk & Contract Management | Workforce and Labor
December 28, 2017

Terms of Subcontract Signed After a Project is Complete Can Be Applied Retroactively

Conditions precedent must be proven.  

An article in Florida Construction Update by Sanjo S. Shatley contains a detailed account of Fifth District Court of Appeal’s decision in Don Facciobene, Inc. v. Hough Roofing , Inc., Case Nos. 5DI5-1527, July 21, 2107, in which the court “addressed the issue of retroactive application of a construction subcontract on the basis of a merger clause…”

Don Facciobene, Inc. (DFI), a general contractor, hired Hough Roofing, Inc. (HRI) to perform the roofing required for the renovation of a building in Melbourne, Fla. Mr. Shatley explains in detail the contractual and working relationship between the two companies that led to the case before the Florida Court of Appeal.

To summarize briefly—“DFI’s project manager signed HRI’s proposal” before HRI began its work. “According to the proposal…payment was due on completion. HRI began work on the roof on April 15, 2011, without a signed subcontract. However, DFI and HRI ultimately executed a subcontract on June 8, 2011, even though HRI had mostly finished its work by the end of May.” The payment terms for the subcontract were significantly different from those in the proposal.

A dispute arose and DFI refused to pay HRI. DFI claimed it owed HRI nothing because the roofer breached the terms of the post-completion subcontract agreement. DFI claimed the subcontract was invalid because it had substantially completed its work before the agreement was executed.

The trial court ruled in favor of HRI but agreed with DFI that the amount they owed HRI should be reduced because the roofer had not complied with several “unspecified conditions precedent.”

The Court of Appeal reversed the lower court’s ruling “holding that the trial court’s decision not to apply the subcontract retroactively was error in light of the merger clause contained in the subcontract. The Fifth District reasoned that the merger clause required retroactive application because it acted to replace the original contract with the new one.”

However, the court also found that retroactive application of the subcontract did not bar “HRI from receiving any payment at all due to HRI’s failure to comply with the conditions precedent.”

Although the Court of Appeal ruled in favor of DFI based upon the application of legal precedent, it, in essence, granted HRI equitable relief because DFI failed to provide sufficient evidence of HRI’s failure to comply with the conditions precedent.

Source—

Retroactive Application of a Construction Subcontract Containing a Merger Clause? Florida’s Fifth District Court of Alleal Answers in the Affirmative, Sanjo S. Shatley, Florida Construction Update, Aug. 25, 2017.

Economic Forecasts•Ethics and Compliance•Infrastructure and Transportation•Insurance and Surety•Latest News•Litigation Strategies/Dispute Resolution•News•Risk & Contract Management•Workforce and Labor

SHARE

Share on Email
Share on Linkedin
Share on Facebook
Share on Pinterest
Share on Twitter
← Previous Article Next Article →
Latest News Latest NewsNews

AGC: “Extreme” Price Hikes for Steel and Aluminum

“The huge increases in steel and aluminum tariffs appears to have enabled domestic producers to push up their selling prices,” said Ken Simonson, the association’s chief economist.

Latest News Latest NewsNews

NYC Attorney Confirms: Defects on the Rise

Carol A. Sigmond, partner at Greenspoon Marder LLP, is seeing a trend; construction defects are on the rise.

Latest News Latest NewsNews

AGC: “Extreme” Price Hikes for Steel and Aluminum

“The huge increases in steel and aluminum tariffs appears to have enabled domestic producers to push up their selling prices,” said Ken Simonson, the association’s chief economist.

Latest News Latest NewsNews

Pricing Risk in Construction – CSC Session Preview

How do you factor in risk from tariffs, immigration crackdowns, and political unrest? CSC will tackle it all.

Latest News Latest NewsNews

Tariffs Drive Up Prices On Key Construction Materials

Steep tariff increases on aluminum and steel, along with a recent tariff on raw copper, drove the producer price index.

Latest News Latest NewsNews

Expanding Roles for In-House Counsel

According to John Fedun, many services that have traditionally been outsourced are now being brought in-house.

Latest News Latest NewsNews

Conference Connections and In-Person Education 

Why spend the time, money, and effort in the digital age? We asked why CSC attendees continue to make the trip.

Latest News Latest NewsNews

Construction Spending Decreases by 0.3 Percent

It's the largest year-over-year decrease since February 2019, according to an analysis by the AGC.

SHOW INFORMATION

SIGN UP

Register now for the opportunity to connect with thousands of atttendees and vendors

Register
Sponsor / Inquire
FOLLOW US ON
  • Follow
  • Follow
  • Follow
Emerald Logo
© 2025 Emerald X, LLC. All Rights Reserved
ABOUTCAREERSAUTHORIZED SERVICE PROVIDERSEVENT STANDARDS OF CONDUCTYour Privacy ChoicesTERMS OF USEPRIVACY POLICY